Rollkur has finally reached the National Press and is receiving the coverage it deserves to raise awareness.

The Observer printed the following article on Sunday 3 January 2010

An international row over allegedly "cruel" training methods is threatening to engulf the elite world of top-class equestrian sport ahead of the 2012 Olympics.

The controversy over what is being called "the blue-tongue scandal" has led the British Horse Society to demand an urgent inquiry into the practices being used on some of the world's most expensive competition horses.

Tens of thousands of people have signed online petitions or sent letters of protest to the sport's governing body, the Fédération Equestre Internationale (FEI), based in Switzerland. There is also talk on social networking websites of a boycott of the 2012 Olympic equestrian event in south London, at which some 23,000 spectators are expected.

The furore began when a video of a dressage horse ridden using a technique called rollkur – the practice of drawing the horse's neck round in a deep curve so its nose almost touches its chest – was posted on YouTube. It showed Swedish rider Patrik Kittel at October's World Cup dressage qualifiers at Odense in Denmark warming up his horse, Watermill Scandic, for a sustained period of time in the position, also known as hyperflexion. The horse's tongue appears to loll out and go blue. Kittel has since received death threats.

The incident has caused a "phenomenal reaction", says dressage trainer and author Lady Sylvia Loch. "It is a shocking symptom of where the sport is going, it's the tip of the iceberg. What is going on behind closed doors in the training of these horses is very wrong.

"Dressage should be about lightness, freedom of movement and a partnership between horse and rider. Rollkur is so, so cruel. The horse can only see its own feet, so it is reliant on the rider for balance which is simply psychological torture."

Loch believes the sport's good name is under threat. "Dressage should be a delightful ballet where the work looks effortless. It doesn't need vile and unnatural methods. Horses shouldn't be brainwashed like this."

***Supporters of rollkur say it is a tool to improve the suppleness of a horse. "In the right hands it is a valuable training method, and it cannot make a horse's tongue go blue, no matter what people seem to think," said Roly Owers, of the World Horse Welfare charity.

"Current rules do not allow prolonged or extensive use of rollkur. However, the incident has brought into focus that issues need to be ironed out. I wouldn't like a ban, as the method will simply be used albeit not in public. It will go underground.

"I don't think that people inside the sport realise the strength of feeling that is out there. There has been quite a phenomenal reaction to this, and clearly we want to see the Olympics bring more people into equestrian sports, not drive them away."

In its letter to the FEI asking it to investigate, the British Horse Society's chairman, Patrick Print, wrote: "In our view, the concerns so widely expressed are reasonable and therefore deserving of an urgent two-part investigation: first, an inquiry into the treatment of this particular horse on this particular occasion; and, second, a broader inquiry into the ethics and consequences of hyperflexion.

"Please note that we pass no comment on the aesthetics of seeing a competition horse contorted in a way it never appears to choose for itself. Our concern is only to speak out when we believe that the welfare of horses demands it."

The FEI said it was taking the issue seriously. "FEI's main concern has always been, and will always be, the welfare of the horse. We are taking the issues raised in the video and in the comments made by members of the public very seriously and have opened a full investigation," a spokeswoman said.

Dressage, invented to train horses for war, became an Olympic discipline in 1912. Horses sell for anything between £10,000 and £500,000. Although more research is in the pipeline, evidence to date is inconclusive, leaving rollkur an undecided issue for bodies such as British Dressage.

"We take the welfare of the horse very seriously, and we have a strong policy against anything that distresses a horse, but things are relative to each horse," said Claire Booth, a spokeswoman for British Dressage. "Trotting a horse in small circles for a long time can be cruel, but for a short time is a perfectly acceptable training method. Dressage judges are looking for a happy athlete in the arena, and that's not going to be achieved by force."

In an interview with Horse and Hound magazine, Kittel, the rider at the centre of the storm, said he had been misrepresented. "Scandic was a little hot at Odense, so I rode him for longer than usual. Throughout every training session, including this one, I give my horses walk breaks. I did not ride Scandic in this depicted frame for the entire duration of the training as implied.

"Scandic sometimes plays with his tongue. During the filmed period of my training, he caught his tongue over or between the bits. I stopped when I noticed and put it back in the right place."

Feedback

The British Horse Society - Published in The Observer Sunday 10th January 2010

Dear Sir,

The most disturbing aspect of Tracy McVeigh’s article on the cruel treatment of horses (“Olympics row over horse ‘cruelty’, 3 January) was the assertion by World Horse Welfare that hyperflexion – that is to say, the extreme flexion of a horse’s neck – is “a valuable training method”. I fear WHW fails to make the important distinction between what is valuable and what is ethical. Horses do not volunteer to participate in any sport, for which the quid pro quo is that the horse’s welfare must be our paramount concern. In comparison with this, the ‘value’ of the horse’s performance comes nowhere at all, a moral standpoint with which I would have hoped the FEI’s welfare adviser would have concurred.

Remembering that “hyper-“ in this context means “in excess”, The British Horse Society’s position on hyperflexion is clear. It is cruel and should not be countenanced.

Yours sincerely,
Patrick Print
FBHS
Chairman, The British Horse Society     

World Horse Welfare - Taken from their Website (www.worldhorsewelfare.org)

In a recent article in the Observer newspaper, the quote attributed to World Horse Welfare with regards to the practice of Rollkur was not entirely correct.

World Horse Welfare does not believe that Rollkur is a "valuable training method". Our comment was that there are many people within the equestrian world who feel that Rollkur is a valuable training method, although clearly there are many people who take the contrary view. We also stressed that Rollkur, like any training method, can cause great harm if it is misused.

World Horse Welfare is taking a stance on this issue. Current FEI rules do not allow prolonged or excessive use of Rollkur. We are seeking robust guidance for stewards at FEI events as to what “excessive” and “prolonged” use of Rollkur means in practice. We are also pushing for robust research to look at whether there is a welfare issue involved in training techniques using Rollkur.

Horse & Hound (Richard Davison Comment) - Published 7 January 2010

While some dressage followers were surprised at the article on The Guardian’s website on 3 January entitled “Olympics row over horse ‘cruelty’”.  I actually found author Tracey McVeigh’s copy to be pretty well balanced.  Of course, I am not including the headline – that is another matter whose sole purpose is to make people stop to read.

For those of us in the equestrian world, this is now “old news” and the only surprising thing is that they didn’t use it earlier.  But then, this is the sort of thing that is very easy for editors to roll out at any time.

With no shelf life, it’s a handy thing to have “in the can”.  And the great thing about the whiff of a boycott is that it’s a great reason to keep updating readers on the topic.  This subject has already had mainstream media attention in other countries and I am sure there will be more to come.  But let’s hope for all of us that the coverage will remain balanced and proportionate.

***Since the publication of this article in the Observer, the Newspaper have changed the article on their Website.  The Paragraph containing the statement from Roly Owers has been changed to the following.

Others say it is a tool to improve the suppleness of a horse. "There are many people in the equestrian world who view rollkur as a valuable training method although clearly there are many people who take the contrary view" said Roly Owers of the World Horse Welfare charity, "but in my view rollkur was not the cause of Watermill Scandic's tongue going blue".